Facebook Instagram Twitter Linkedin
Ryan Orsatti Law Firm Logo
210-525-1200

When the Other Driver Was Using Personal Insurance for Business Purposes: What San Antonio Drivers Need to Know

When the Other Driver Was Using Personal Insurance for Business Purposes: What San Antonio Drivers Need to Know

Introduction

Finding out the driver who hit you was using their personal insurance while conducting business activities can significantly complicate your personal injury claim in Texas. This situation creates unique challenges that many accident victims don’t anticipate when seeking compensation for their injuries.

In San Antonio, where commercial activity continues to grow alongside rideshare and delivery services, these cases are becoming increasingly common. Understanding the differences between personal and commercial auto insurance policies—and what happens when someone improperly uses personal coverage for business activities—can be crucial to protecting your rights after an accident.

Personal vs. Commercial Auto Insurance: Understanding the Difference

Personal auto insurance policies are designed specifically for individual, non-commercial use of a vehicle. These policies typically cover:

Commercial auto insurance, on the other hand, protects vehicles used primarily for business purposes. This coverage is designed to address the higher risks associated with business driving, including:

The key distinction lies in the risk assessment: commercial policies account for increased mileage, different driving patterns, and potentially more valuable cargo or higher liability exposure that comes with business activities.

Business Use Exclusions in Personal Auto Policies

Most personal auto insurance policies contain specific exclusions for business or commercial use. These exclusions can be found in the fine print of policy documents, often stating that coverage does not apply when the vehicle is:

Insurance companies include these exclusions because business use typically involves more time on the road, different driving patterns, and potentially higher risk scenarios than personal driving.

Common Scenarios in San Antonio

San Antonio’s growing economy has led to an increase in several scenarios where drivers might improperly use personal insurance for business activities:

Rideshare Drivers Between Assignments

Rideshare services like Uber and Lyft have created a complex insurance situation. While these companies provide some commercial coverage when drivers are actively transporting passengers or en route to pick them up, there are “gap periods” when drivers are logged into the app but haven’t accepted a ride. During these periods, the rideshare company’s coverage is limited, and the driver’s personal policy may not apply if it excludes business use.

Food and Package Delivery

The explosion of food delivery services (DoorDash, UberEats, Grubhub) and increased package delivery has put more drivers on San Antonio roads who may be using personal vehicles with personal insurance for commercial activities.

Real Estate Agents

Real estate professionals frequently drive clients to property showings. While this is clearly business activity, many agents use their personal vehicles with personal insurance policies that may exclude such use.

Mobile Service Providers

Plumbers, electricians, landscapers, and other service professionals who drive to clients’ locations often use their personal vehicles for business purposes without appropriate commercial coverage.

When a driver causes an accident while engaging in business activities but only carries personal auto insurance, several legal complications can arise:

Insurance Coverage Denials

The at-fault driver’s insurance company may deny coverage based on the business use exclusion in their policy. This can leave accident victims with limited options for recovering compensation.

Insurance Bad Faith Claims

If an insurance company initially accepts a claim but later denies it after discovering business use, this can potentially lead to bad faith insurance practices claims, especially if the insurer knew or should have known about the business use from the beginning.

Vicarious Liability

In some cases, the company for whom the driver was performing services may bear liability under theories of vicarious liability or respondeat superior (when an employer is responsible for the actions of employees performed within the scope of employment).

Steps to Take if You Discover Business Use After an Accident

If you’ve been injured in an accident in San Antonio and later discover the at-fault driver was using personal insurance for business activities, consider these important steps:

Gather evidence that demonstrates the other driver was engaged in business activities at the time of the accident:

2. Investigate All Potential Insurance Coverages

While the driver’s personal policy may deny coverage, other insurance policies might apply:

3. Consider All Potentially Liable Parties

In Texas personal injury law, multiple parties may share liability:

4. Act Quickly to Preserve Evidence

Evidence of business use can disappear quickly. Prompt action is essential:

Texas Laws Regarding Insurance Requirements

Texas law requires all drivers to maintain minimum liability insurance of:

However, these minimums apply to personal auto insurance. Commercial vehicles often require higher coverage limits, depending on the type of vehicle and its use. The failure to maintain appropriate commercial insurance when engaging in business activities may constitute negligence per se (negligence as a matter of law) in some circumstances.

Texas courts have addressed several cases involving personal insurance used for business purposes:

In Progressive County Mutual Insurance Co. v. Kelley, the court upheld an insurer’s denial of coverage based on business use exclusions when the policyholder was delivering pizzas at the time of the accident.

The Texas Supreme Court has generally enforced business use exclusions in personal auto policies, finding them to be clear and unambiguous contract provisions that policyholders should be aware of when purchasing insurance.

Special Considerations for San Antonio Drivers

San Antonio’s unique characteristics create special considerations for these cases:

Military Personnel

With several military bases in the area, service members sometimes use personal vehicles for military-related duties. This can create confusion about whether personal or government insurance applies.

Cross-Border Commerce

San Antonio’s proximity to Mexico means some drivers may be engaged in international business activities, adding another layer of complexity to insurance coverage questions.

Tourism and Service Economy

The city’s robust tourism industry creates many situations where personal vehicles are used for commercial purposes related to hospitality and tourism services.

How an Experienced Personal Injury Attorney Can Help

When facing a case involving personal insurance used for business purposes, an experienced San Antonio personal injury attorney can:

Preventing Similar Situations

If you use your vehicle for any business purposes, consider these preventative measures:

Conclusion

Discovering that the driver who caused your accident in San Antonio was using personal insurance for business purposes creates significant challenges in your injury claim. However, with proper legal guidance, these obstacles can be overcome. Understanding the interplay between personal and commercial insurance policies, recognizing signs of business use, and taking prompt action to secure evidence are essential steps toward protecting your right to fair compensation.

If you’ve been injured in such a situation, consulting with a knowledgeable personal injury attorney who understands the nuances of commercial vehicle liability can make all the difference in the outcome of your case. The sooner you seek legal assistance after your accident, the better positioned you’ll be to navigate these complex insurance issues and secure the compensation you deserve.