Understanding Secondary Gain in Personal Injury Cases

Secondary gain is a crucial concept in personal injury cases that can significantly influence the outcome of a claim. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore what secondary gain is, how it manifests in personal injury cases, and its potential impact on legal proceedings.

What is Secondary Gain?

Secondary gain refers to the external benefits that individuals might receive as a result of their medical condition or injury. These benefits can include financial compensation, attention, care, or relief from responsibilities. In the context of personal injury law, secondary gain can sometimes lead to exaggeration or prolongation of symptoms, complicating the legal process.

Types of Secondary Gain

  1. External Gains: These include monetary benefits such as insurance payouts, disability benefits, and legal compensation. The prospect of these gains can sometimes influence the behavior of claimants.
  2. Internal Gains: These are psychological benefits like increased attention, sympathy from others, or a sense of being taken care of. These can also play a role in how individuals report and manage their symptoms.

Secondary Gain in Personal Injury Cases

In personal injury cases, secondary gain can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it highlights the genuine needs and suffering of the plaintiff. On the other hand, it can be used by the defense to suggest that the plaintiff is exaggerating or malingering.

  1. Credibility of the Plaintiff: The presence of secondary gain can affect the credibility of the plaintiff’s testimony. Defense attorneys may argue that the plaintiff has a financial motive to exaggerate their injuries.
  2. Medical Examinations: Independent medical examinations (IMEs) often consider the possibility of secondary gain. Medical experts might look for inconsistencies between the reported symptoms and the objective findings.
  3. Settlement Negotiations: The potential for secondary gain can influence settlement negotiations. Insurers may be more cautious in offering settlements if they suspect secondary gain is influencing the plaintiff’s claims.

Mitigating the Effects of Secondary Gain

  1. Accurate Medical Documentation: Ensuring thorough and accurate medical documentation can help in mitigating the impact of secondary gain arguments. Consistent medical records that reflect the true extent of injuries are crucial.
  2. Expert Testimony: Medical and psychological experts can provide testimony to explain the nature of secondary gain and differentiate between legitimate suffering and potential exaggeration.
  3. Transparency and Honesty: Encouraging plaintiffs to be transparent and honest about their symptoms and the impact on their lives can help maintain credibility.


Understanding secondary gain is essential for navigating personal injury cases effectively. At Ryan Orsatti Law, we specialize in representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases, ensuring that legitimate claims are supported by robust evidence and expert testimony. If you have questions about how secondary gain might affect your case, contact us today for a consultation.

References and Further Reading

Contact Ryan Orsatti Law

For expert legal representation in personal injury cases, visit Ryan Orsatti Law or call us at (210) 525-1200.