What is a Mediator’s Proposal?

A mediator’s proposal is a unique tool used during mediation to help disputing parties reach a settlement. In Texas personal injury law, this proposal can play a pivotal role in resolving cases without the need for prolonged litigation. Mediators, who are neutral third parties, use their expertise to suggest a fair settlement based on the information provided by both parties.

How Does a Mediator’s Proposal Work?

  1. Mediation Session: During mediation, both parties present their cases, including evidence and arguments. The mediator facilitates discussions, aiming to help the parties reach a mutually acceptable resolution.
  2. Proposal Development: If the parties cannot agree, the mediator may offer a proposal. This proposal is a non-binding suggestion for settlement, crafted after considering all aspects of the case.
  3. Confidential Consideration: Each party reviews the mediator’s proposal confidentially. They have the opportunity to accept or reject the proposal without disclosing their decision to the other party.
  4. Acceptance and Resolution: If both parties accept the mediator’s proposal, the dispute is settled according to the terms suggested by the mediator. If either party rejects it, the mediation may continue, or the case might proceed to trial.

Benefits of a Mediator’s Proposal

When is a Mediator’s Proposal Used?

Mediator’s proposals are often utilized when parties are at an impasse, and traditional negotiation techniques have failed. It is particularly useful in complex personal injury cases where emotions run high, and the stakes are significant.

In Texas, mediation is a common practice in personal injury cases. According to the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, courts can refer cases to mediation to encourage settlement. This legal framework supports the use of mediator’s proposals as an effective tool for dispute resolution.

Real-World Example

Consider a case where an individual suffers injuries in a car accident due to another driver’s negligence. Despite clear evidence, the insurance company offers a low settlement. During mediation, both parties present their arguments, but negotiations stall. The mediator, understanding the case’s complexities, offers a proposal that bridges the gap between the parties’ positions. Both sides, after confidential deliberation, agree to the proposal, resulting in a fair settlement without further litigation.


A mediator’s proposal is a powerful mechanism in Texas personal injury law, offering a balanced, confidential, and efficient pathway to dispute resolution. By understanding and utilizing this tool, parties can often avoid the prolonged and costly process of going to trial.

For more information on mediation and personal injury law, you can visit Texas Mediation Trainer Roundtable and the State Bar of Texas.

By focusing on the unique aspects of mediator’s proposals and their application in Texas personal injury law, this blog aims to provide valuable insights for individuals navigating the complexities of legal disputes.