Facebook Instagram Twitter Linkedin
Ryan Orsatti Law Firm Logo
210-525-1200

How Insurance Companies Undervalue Vehicle Damage in San Antonio Accident Claims

How Insurance Companies Undervalue Vehicle Damage in San Antonio Accident Claims

Understanding the True Cost of Vehicle Damage After a San Antonio Collision

If you’ve been involved in a car accident in San Antonio, you’re likely facing the frustrating process of getting fair compensation for your damaged vehicle. Unfortunately, insurance companies employ numerous tactics to minimize payouts for vehicle damage claims, leaving accident victims with insufficient funds to properly repair their vehicles or replace totaled ones.

At Ryan Orsatti Law, we’ve witnessed countless cases where insurance companies systematically undervalued vehicle damage claims in San Antonio. This article reveals the methods insurers use to reduce payouts and provides practical strategies to protect your rights and secure fair compensation.

Common Tactics Insurance Companies Use to Undervalue Vehicle Damage

1. Disputing the Pre-Accident Value of Your Vehicle

Insurance companies often begin by challenging your vehicle’s pre-accident value, particularly for older models or those with higher mileage. They typically use internal valuation software that tends to produce lower estimates than market reality.

The Texas Department of Insurance requires insurers to use “fair, reasonable, and equitable” methods when determining vehicle value, but the definition of these terms leaves considerable room for interpretation. According to the Texas Administrative Code, insurers must provide a detailed explanation of their valuation method upon request, but many San Antonio drivers remain unaware of this right.

2. Using “Comparable” Vehicles That Aren’t Truly Comparable

When determining your vehicle’s pre-accident value, insurers often cite “comparable” vehicles for sale in the San Antonio area. However, these comparisons frequently involve vehicles with higher mileage, older model years, or inferior trim packages.

A 2023 study by the Consumer Federation of America found that insurance company valuations nationwide were an average of 30% below actual replacement costs. This discrepancy is particularly pronounced in high-demand markets like San Antonio, where vehicle prices have increased significantly in recent years.

3. Pushing for Aftermarket Parts Instead of OEM Components

One of the most common cost-cutting measures is the insistence on using aftermarket parts rather than Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) components. While Texas law allows this practice, many insurers fail to disclose the potential impact on vehicle safety, warranty coverage, and resale value.

According to the Texas Department of Insurance, insurers must disclose if they’re using aftermarket parts, but they don’t have to use OEM parts unless specifically required by your policy. This subtle distinction leaves many San Antonio drivers with repairs that don’t restore their vehicles to pre-accident condition.

4. Depreciating Parts That Shouldn’t Be Depreciated

Insurance adjusters in San Antonio routinely apply depreciation to vehicle parts that shouldn’t be depreciated. While some wear-and-tear items like tires and batteries reasonably depreciate over time, many components maintain their value until damaged.

The Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel notes that certain safety components, such as airbags and seatbelts, should never be depreciated when calculating repair costs. Nevertheless, many San Antonio claimants discover depreciation applied across their entire repair estimate.

5. Disputing the Necessity of Certain Repairs

Another common tactic is challenging the necessity of specific repairs recommended by your mechanic or body shop. Insurance adjusters often claim that certain damages existed before the accident or that proposed repairs are excessive.

This practice is particularly common with underlying structural damage or electronic systems that may be affected but not immediately apparent. According to data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, claims involving disputed repairs take an average of 30 days longer to resolve and result in payouts approximately 40% lower than initial repair estimates.

6. Pressuring You to Use Their “Preferred” Repair Shops

Insurance companies frequently steer San Antonio claimants toward their network of “preferred” repair facilities. While these shops may offer convenience, they often operate under agreements with insurers to keep costs below certain thresholds.

Under Texas law, specifically Texas Insurance Code §1952.301, insurers cannot require you to use a specific repair shop. You have the right to choose your preferred repair facility, even if the insurance company suggests otherwise.

7. Manipulating Total Loss Thresholds

In Texas, a vehicle is typically considered a total loss when repair costs exceed a certain percentage of its actual cash value. Most insurers set this threshold between 70-80%, though it’s not strictly defined by state law.

By undervaluing your vehicle’s pre-accident worth and overestimating repair costs, insurers can manipulate this equation to their advantage. This may result in your vehicle being declared a total loss when repairs would be more beneficial, or vice versa, depending on which outcome costs the insurance company less.

The San Antonio Market: Unique Challenges

San Antonio’s vehicle market presents specific challenges that exacerbate these undervaluation issues:

  1. Higher-than-average vehicle prices: The San Antonio metropolitan area has experienced significant increases in used vehicle prices, outpacing many other Texas markets.
  2. Limited public transportation options: San Antonio’s relatively limited public transit system means vehicle owners are more dependent on their cars, creating additional hardship when repairs are delayed or undervalued.
  3. Climate considerations: San Antonio’s climate, with intense heat and occasional flooding, creates unique vehicle maintenance needs that insurance adjusters from other regions may not fully appreciate.
  4. Specialized vehicle market: The San Antonio area has a higher-than-average percentage of trucks and SUVs, which often have more complex repair requirements and higher parts costs.

How to Protect Yourself Against Vehicle Damage Undervaluation

1. Document Everything From the Moment of the Accident

Comprehensive documentation is your strongest defense against undervaluation. After ensuring everyone’s safety and fulfilling legal reporting requirements:

This documentation establishes a clear record that can contradict inaccurate claims by insurance adjusters.

2. Get Multiple Independent Repair Estimates

Don’t rely solely on the insurance company’s assessment. Obtain written estimates from at least three reputable San Antonio repair shops. Focus on established businesses with certified technicians and positive reviews.

These independent evaluations provide leverage when negotiating with insurers and may reveal necessary repairs the insurance adjuster overlooked or disputed.

3. Research Your Vehicle’s Actual Market Value

Before accepting any valuation, research your vehicle’s actual market value in the San Antonio area. Useful resources include:

Print these comparables and be prepared to present them during negotiations.

4. Understand Your Insurance Policy’s Specific Language

Review your policy carefully, paying particular attention to:

Many San Antonio drivers discover too late that their policy contains limitations they weren’t aware of when purchasing coverage.

5. Consider Hiring a Public Adjuster for Significant Claims

For substantial damage claims, consider hiring a licensed public adjuster. These professionals work for you, not the insurance company, and have expertise in identifying undervaluation tactics.

The Texas Association of Public Insurance Adjusters can help you find a qualified professional in the San Antonio area.

6. Know When to Consult with an Experienced San Antonio Attorney

If the insurance company refuses to offer fair compensation despite your diligent efforts, it may be time to consult with a qualified personal injury attorney who understands San Antonio’s specific insurance landscape.

An experienced attorney can:

Texas law provides several protections against insurance undervaluation, though they’re often underutilized:

  1. The Prompt Payment of Claims Act (Texas Insurance Code Chapter 542) requires insurers to process claims within specific timeframes. Violations can result in penalties and interest.
  2. Bad Faith Insurance Practices (Texas Insurance Code Chapter 541) prohibits unfair claims settlement practices, including undervaluing damage without reasonable investigation.
  3. Diminished Value Claims are recognized in Texas, allowing you to seek compensation for your vehicle’s reduced market value after repairs.
  4. The Deceptive Trade Practices Act provides additional protections against misleading insurance practices and can allow for treble damages in certain circumstances.

The Hidden Costs of Accepting Undervalued Vehicle Damage Claims

Many San Antonio drivers accept inadequate settlements without understanding the long-term consequences:

  1. Safety Concerns: Inadequate repairs using inferior parts may compromise vehicle safety and create liability issues if another accident occurs.
  2. Accelerated Depreciation: Improper repairs often lead to accelerated depreciation, costing thousands when you eventually sell or trade the vehicle.
  3. Warranty Implications: Using aftermarket parts or unapproved repair methods can void manufacturer warranties, creating substantial future expenses.
  4. Insurance Premium Impacts: Despite receiving inadequate compensation, you’ll likely still face premium increases following a claim.

When Litigation Becomes Necessary

While most vehicle damage disputes can be resolved through negotiation, some cases require litigation. In San Antonio courts, successful vehicle damage lawsuits typically involve one or more of these elements:

An experienced San Antonio personal injury attorney can evaluate your specific situation and determine whether litigation represents a viable and worthwhile option.

Conclusion: Knowledge Is Your Best Protection

Insurance companies rely on claimants’ lack of information and the pressure of being without transportation to force quick, undervalued settlements. By understanding the tactics outlined in this article and implementing the suggested countermeasures, San Antonio drivers can level the playing field.

Remember that fair compensation isn’t just about receiving enough money to make minimum repairs—it’s about being restored to the same position you were in before the accident occurred, both in terms of vehicle condition and financial standing.

If you’re facing resistance from an insurance company after a San Antonio accident, consider consulting with the experienced team at Ryan Orsatti Law. Our knowledge of local insurance practices and commitment to client advocacy can make the difference between an inadequate settlement and the full compensation you deserve.

This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case involves unique circumstances that require individual evaluation by a qualified attorney.

© 2025 Ryan Orsatti Law